Anything that "keeps water
Anything that "keeps water out" will also keep water in. There aren't any viable shoes that do a good job keeping water out - it still comes in through the openings, at the very least. So, after a not-totally-shallow creek crossing, you'll just have a shoe full of water. Not sure why you want such a shoe.
Year-round, even running through Detroit's icy slush puddles, I prefer a shoe that drains well. Coupled with a nice Drymax or wool sock. Right now, for me (but NOT Nyah), that'd be the Pace Glove (or Trail Glove).