Welcome, Irish. You want to
Welcome, Irish. You want to transition from a traditional running shoe (TRS) to something more minimal, not barefoot? It would be best if you could learn a proper barefoot running form first before you go to other footwear. If you can, you will lessen the likelihood of doing too much too soon. Minimal footwear tends to make the runner think they can run as far and as fast as they could while running in TRSs, when in fact, it takes time to step down from 1-1/2" of foam and padding to near flat to the ground elevation. Your calves, Achilles, and plantar fascia has shortened by about 1-1/2", and if you were to pick up with minimalist shoes where you left off with boat anchors, you are pending serious injury. If you still decide to go from something minimal, please just take it slow and easy, and basically, start over from scratch. Relearn how to run, the right way.
With that said, a lot of people like the Vibrams. I don't know anything about the other two.
Glad you're here.